Sunday, 4 February 2018

ASD in the primary years - low level bullying

I had to nudge, poke and generally humour my ASD step daughter into smiling this morning. The journey to school ended with us both singing along to some 80s classics, and she left the car seemingly full of beans. On reflection I’m not sure if the need to make her smile had arisen from my own need to know she is ok in herself. Her expressionless face is like a blank canvass waiting to be painted; a seemingly emotionless child. Yet this is not to say she is not contented. I however am a social being, and need those visual reassurances. I hadn’t assumed she was unhappy, I wanted to know that she was happy. She has so many social challenges through the school day, that it pains me to think that she might start her day on anything other than a positive note.

With this considered, I continue to wonder about the depth of her social communication needs. Conflict is becoming more regular, and she is now subject to low level bullying with her class mates talking about her behind her back. She knows this is going on, yet is not phased by this ‘because they are nice to my face and that is all that matters’. So currently in school she is only avoiding physical conflict due to her lack of theory of mind. Her social processing acting as a barrier to feeling hurt by the actions of her peer group.For me this raise two questions. The first being what will happen when she experiences face to face bullying, the second, how should we be supporting the development of theory of mind without causing her greater anxiety? The first question is easy to answer, she will end up hitting someone. There is no shadow of a doubt that her actions will seem completely justified. There are already instances of this, yet no matter what is said to her, even with the school’s ‘restorative justice’ process, she will not accept the other person’s point of view. Once she has worked out ‘what they want me to say’, the process ends. Her only learning being a set of phases to appease school staff. She openly admits to this strategy, giving a factual account of what was said and how she then processed the information. She is a cleaver little girl. So what can we do as adults? We accept that we are not always going to be able to help her understand someone else’s view or feelings. We let her know that it is ok to feel that way. We also reinforce the boundaries that exist with those feelings. Making sure she understanding the limits that must be applied. This isn’t easy as so many situations require a range of responses, yet hitting is never ok. Or is it? In self defence? If you’re being attacked? A stranger? As parents we walk a fine line of teaching our children the flexibility of rules and the context in which they apply. So many of these are founded in a social or environmental context. In the primary school setting, these variables are limited, the environment and structure and process of growing through school from the early years all helping control these. Secondary school is going to be a different matter, where social rules and communication outside of the classroom are uncontrollable. These will start before school; the bus journey will be a sensory overload for her, peer group communication could possibly present her with misunderstanding and conflict. With no adult to her scaffold her understanding or manage her behaviour, where will this lead? Again this presents us a parents with a dilemma. How do you help support in an environment you can’t control. It’s an experience that is impossible to replicate, leaving no opportunity to help with prior learning. The way we believe this is possible is to manage her reactions whenever she feels there is an injustice. To teach her to use each new challenging experience as a learning ground. Not to react, yet to remember events in order to work through them to get a better understanding for the next time they arise. This then provides her with a starting point for interaction if a similar situation were to arise again. This is not to say she’ll achieve the outcomes she wants. Yet it may enable her to successfully interact in a range of social situations. This of course is a voyage of discovery, and we learn everyday that her view of the world is different to ours, and it is for us to adapt in order to provide her with the support she needs.As for the second question, ‘how do we support the development of theory of mind without causing greater anxiety?’ We can’t develop theory of mind, only the understanding of it. If you can’t infer the thoughts or feelings of others, then this is just how it is. You can teach what these might be, yet it is the empathy one feels in conjunction with this inference that creates the true understanding. Yet having a better knowledge other people’s feelings and what this means to them is something that can be learnt. It will not necessarily provide an emotional connection, just information that can be used during the interaction process. As one young ASD adult size aid to me after supporting a crying friend ‘I tried empathy, yet I have no idea if it worked, how am I meant to tell?’. So teaching understanding of theory of mind appears to be essential. Will it cause greater anxiety tough, perhaps it will. Yet as a skill set it will be invaluable in providing better life outcomes. Do I want my stepdaughter to fully understand the seemingly spiteful actions of her peer group with all that this means, I’m not sure. I think I’ll leave that decision to her mum.