Wednesday, 7 March 2018

ASD Training : 3 teachers statements on classroom behaviour explored.

'I was told to  F-OFF today by a year 8 and I've had enough. If he's not expelled, I'm leaving'

'I expect students to face the front and make eye contact when I'm teaching; if they don't, I send them out of class.'

'I have another 30 kids in the class, why should I focus on just them?'


The three statements above are examples of feedback I've had from teachers during training on supporting students with a diagnosis of ASD. Each of which I believe represents an area for consideration, with each of these statements providing an opportunity for reflection and learning. This blog aims to provide a little understanding of the view behind each statement and the how this can be used to develop teaching practices and positive student relationships.

'I was told to F**K OFF today by a year 8 and I've had enough...... 

This was said to me by a mature male teacher from a large mainstream secondary school. He was outraged by the swearing and felt that this was beyond unacceptable, and that if that behaviour wasn't addressed with expulsion, then all areas of behaviour would slip. My first thought was 'what did you say to the student?'. If indeed behavioural expectations are so high in this school, what would have moved a student to use such language? In this context, I would immediately assume the use of this language would indicate a need to be heard. Even if the swearing is associated with a trivial matter, I can only draw the conclusion that there is another factor that needs to be addressed. Expulsion in my mind is completely counterproductive; This 'disciplinary warranted' behaviour by the student provides the chance to open up a dialogue and start to understand the needs of the individual. A learning opportunity for both the student and professionals. This doesn't mean that sanctions are not put in place, it does mean that when they are, it is with positive outcomes and personal development in mind.

....... If he's not expelled I'm leaving'

This statement is an indication of the tipping point between student behaviour and the attitude of the teacher toward The School. Whether this statement was meant or not, it is reflective of a member of staff feeling unsupported. Obviously there is a role for The School to play to effect change, yet individual teachers often miss the opportunity to empower themselves. This teacher had the chance to take the lead in effectively working with a disengaged student. The chance not only to support academic development, yet to scaffold learning and develop the student's personal and social skills. to teach them how to be heard effectively, providing them with the strategies to be more effective in the school environment. 

Being sworn at by a student in this context isn't a personal insult, it's an indication of a need for support and learning. 

'I expect students to face the front and make eye contact when I'm teaching; if they don't I send them out of class.'

I can't tell you how frustrating it was to hear this from a young relatively newly qualified teacher from a grammar school. I found her expectations and actions toward students to be outdated and inflexible. On enquiring with The School SENCo, I was informed that a number of teachers taught in that way and that there were an increasing number of students 'at risk' due to this approach. I spoke with the teacher to get a better understanding of her view; she had a real passion for imparting knowledge, yet in a clinical way, her mindset being that structure and rules would provide the framework for delivering a lesson. The children were almost secondary in the process. The overall impression being that her job was to teach, not to enable students to learn.

I challenged this approach, indicating that she had spent the training facing her colleagues, and that I doodle when in a lecture. Inferring that you can still learn without eye contact, and that it can help concentration. I suggested that she try a controlled test, allowing elements of 'freedom' during a lesson, monitoring behaviour and knowledge obtained. This methodology providing evidence of any progress or benefits to a change in teaching style. 

There is no reason not to try new things, it allows for a broadening of understanding, even if not meeting the desired outcomes or goals. It's how you do it that is important, and ensuring students are not disadvantaged during the process.


'I have another 30 kids in the class, why should I focus on just them?'

You shouldn't, yet if you feel you are only focusing on 'them', then I'd suggest you need to be doing something different.  There will always be students that you have to invest more time in at different points of the day, week, year. If there is a student or a group of students whom are continuously disengaged, then a change in approach may be needed. Don't think of yourself as being in isolation. Talking to other professionals and sharing challenges can often provide the nuggets of information needed to unlock learning behaviour. Relationships with students are key; these aren't only built in the classroom, and look for opportunities for shared experiences, mutual respect and understanding. 

Investing more time at specific points can have a long term positive impact on engagement.

No comments:

Post a Comment